Forgetting Effects
from UDE's Player Management Forums
Hi...
I have a question about forgetting effects. I have some situations. (Pretend like you were judging and someone called you over and explained these situations to you)
1: Player A activates Crush Card Virus, tributing Destiny Hero Disk Commander. Player B destroys all monsters over 1500 ATK on the field. (No other effects activate.) After that happens, Player A sets two cards and ends his turn. Player B draws and then uses Reinforcements of the Army. Player A remembers that he never checked the hand. Player B says it's too late because now Player A doesn't know what is in the hand in the first place.
What would you do?
What if Player A forgot because Player B did something distracting making him/her forget (answering a cell phone, getting up and coming back, etc)
2: Player X uses Smashing Ground to destroy a face up D. D. Survivor on Player Z's side of the field while Macro Cosmos is face up on the field. Player X attacks with Jinzo - Returner. Player Z takes some damage. After the battle phase, Player X ends his/her turn. Player Z draws a card and continues to Main Phase 1. During Main Phase 1, Player Z remembers that he forgot to return his D. D Survivor. Player X says it is too late to bring it back as he/she already drew a card. Player Z says that it is a mandatory effect to bring it back.
What should happen? Should Survivor come back even if the player forgot?
Thank you in advance
http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/COMMUNITY/forums/thread/1191800.aspx
from UDE's Player Management Forums
Hi...
I have a question about forgetting effects. I have some situations. (Pretend like you were judging and someone called you over and explained these situations to you)
1: Player A activates Crush Card Virus, tributing Destiny Hero Disk Commander. Player B destroys all monsters over 1500 ATK on the field. (No other effects activate.) After that happens, Player A sets two cards and ends his turn. Player B draws and then uses Reinforcements of the Army. Player A remembers that he never checked the hand. Player B says it's too late because now Player A doesn't know what is in the hand in the first place.
What would you do?
What if Player A forgot because Player B did something distracting making him/her forget (answering a cell phone, getting up and coming back, etc)
2: Player X uses Smashing Ground to destroy a face up D. D. Survivor on Player Z's side of the field while Macro Cosmos is face up on the field. Player X attacks with Jinzo - Returner. Player Z takes some damage. After the battle phase, Player X ends his/her turn. Player Z draws a card and continues to Main Phase 1. During Main Phase 1, Player Z remembers that he forgot to return his D. D Survivor. Player X says it is too late to bring it back as he/she already drew a card. Player Z says that it is a mandatory effect to bring it back.
What should happen? Should Survivor come back even if the player forgot?
Thank you in advance
http://entertainment.upperdeck.com/COMMUNITY/forums/thread/1191800.aspx