Search results

  1. S

    HeartofClearWater+relinquished+magicreflector+mons ter?

    "Magic Reflector" won't help "Heart of Clear Water", and not for any of the reasons provided earlier. "Magic Reflector" cannot protect cards from their own inherent self-destruction. This was explained in the rulings for "Swords of Revealing Light". There will not be any check, remove...
  2. S

    correct me if I'm wrong but... (ultimate offering question)

    A Normal Summon is what's resolving, hence why you don't miss the timing for Optional Triggered Effect monsters. If you have a monster in hand when the effect resolves, then you must summon/set it. And just to throw this in there...paying the 500 LPs is a cost to activate the effect. If you...
  3. S

    ritual summmoning vs trap dustshoot/mind crush

    If you no longer have the Ritual Monster in hand, then entire effect of the card goes away. You do not send anything to the Graveyard. It would be similar to this ruling here:
  4. S

    quick question regarding infinite loops

    1st. The Judge List rarely ever replies to anything regarding an issue being discussed on a Forum site. 2nd. "Waboku" doesn't make the ATK of your monster 0. And it clearly states that your monsters cannot be destroyed by battle, so how is that inconsistent?
  5. S

    Chimeratech Overdragon vs RftDD/Dimension Fusion

    What you propose is not possible. "Chimeratech" is a nomi monster and cannot be Special Summoned by any other method than Fusion Summon. So, once he leaves the field, he's not coming back, unless you find a way to put him back into your Fusion Deck and properly Fusion Summon him again.
  6. S

    quick question regarding infinite loops

    Just in case nobody actually read the link posted earlier...I'll just link to the 'relevant' question and answer....lol... http://lists.upperdeck.com/read/messages?id=5477#5477 Enjoy!
  7. S

    quick question regarding infinite loops

    "Cyber Phoenix" will be destroyed in this case since it is the source of the loop.
  8. S

    e hero demise tunder giant...

    You are correct. "Thunder Giant" only cares about his current ATK when resolving his effect. If his ATK is lowered or raised, then the monster(s) he can destroy will change accordingly.
  9. S

    Forced Req

    The effects of "Forced Requisition" and "Appropriate" are considered to be Continuous Effects, NOT Triggered effects. Neither effect uses the chain.
  10. S

    another dumb question...

    To clarify. You do not pay anything when you initially activate (put it on the field) "Mausoleum of the Emperor". When you choose to use the effect, paying the LPs is a cost to activate it's effect. This is identical to how you use "Ultimate Offering".
  11. S

    another dumb question...

    Because any/all Spells/Traps that remain on the field, must do so in order for their effects to properly resolve. Example. "Ultimate Offering". I activate it's effect and pay the 500 LP cost, you chain with "MST" destroying "Ultimate Offering". I don't summon and I'm out 500 LPs. In order...
  12. S

    rare metalmorph

    Yes. The ruling for "Rare Metalmorph" and "Snatch Steal" should answer any issues about cards that have already targeted the monster and cards that continuously target the monster. "Snatch Steal" has already targeted the monster by the time "Rare Metalmorph" resolves, but since it continually...
  13. S

    another dumb question...

    Yes, it needs to remain on the field. It's a Field Spell Card and must follow the rules of all Continuous-type Spell and Trap cards. If it's not on the field when it's effect attempts to resolve, then you don't get it's effect. And paying the LPs is a cost to activate it's effect.
  14. S

    The Six Samurai - Zanji

    Right now, the answer is up to the Head Judge of the event. I had my Judges at the Houston Shonen Jump rule that "Zanji" must survive the attack in order to have his effect work. That means at a minimum, if you want to get his effect, then you'd have to have 3 Six Samurai on the field if you...
  15. S

    rare metalmorph

    Point 1. Which is the biggest point of all....which I have said over and over and over and over and over and over and over.......again... "CHIMERATECH" DOESN'T DESTROY ANYTHING!!!! IT NEVER HAS AND IT NEVER WILL!! "Chimeratech" SENDS all cards on your side of the field to the Graveyard. I...
  16. S

    rare metalmorph

    I would have to say that works just fine. I can't seem to find anything that would suggest it didn't...lol.
  17. S

    ordeal of a traveler vs lord of D

    "Ordeal of a Traveler" does not target, so the Dragon would be returned to the Hand if you called the card wrong. http://lists.upperdeck.com/read/messages?id=4024#4024
  18. S

    Mystic Box and the Six Samurai

    If I'm not mistaken, if the targeted monster is not destroyed, then the other monster will not switch sides. There used to be a ruling about this with "Horus LV6", but I can't seem to locate that ruling anymore...
  19. S

    level 5> toons any to avoid tribs?

    Actually, Toons are considered to be Special Summon only monsters. As such, they must be Special Summoned properly first before they can be Special Summoned by any other means.
Back
Top