Tornado Wall
Attrib: Trap Card
Group: Trap
Icon:Continuous
This card can only be activated when "Umi" is active on the field. As long as "Umi" remains face-up on the field, any damage from attacking monsters to your Life Points becomes 0. When "Umi" is destroyed or removed from the field, this card is also destroyed.
Umi
Attrib: Magic Card
Group: Magic
Icon:Field
Increases the ATK and DEF of all Fish, Sea Serpent, Thunder, and Aqua-Type monsters by 200 points. Also decreases the ATK and DEF of all Machine and Pyro-Type monsters by 200 points.
scenario
player 1 has umi face up and tornado wall face up
player 2 plays another umi from his hand , sending the previus one to grave
the question is
just send umi is enough to trigguer the condition placed on tornado wall?
"When "Umi" is destroyed or removed from the field, this card is also destroyed."
in regards to previous rules on maiden of aqua versus tornado wall versus umi
If "Maiden of the Aqua", "Umi", and "Tornado Wall" are all on your side of the field, and "Umi" is destroyed, "Tornado Wall" is not destroyed because "Maiden of the Aqua" treats the field as "Umi" as soon as "Umi" leaves play.
the answer would be : since the final result of send umi to grave is that umi(2) remain on the field, tornado wall would remain too, by extrapolating the rule above
fact is , i am not satisfied with this rules because the condition placed on "tornado wall"
i also will coment another rule based on toons
"when toon world is destroyd all toons on both sides of the field are destroyed too"
once a condition is placed on toon monsters that they must be destroyed if a toon world leaves the field. it will afct both sides of the field
in similar manner, once the condition place on "tornado wall" is met, he also should leave the field
i will thanks any imput
woltarr
Attrib: Trap Card
Group: Trap
Icon:Continuous
This card can only be activated when "Umi" is active on the field. As long as "Umi" remains face-up on the field, any damage from attacking monsters to your Life Points becomes 0. When "Umi" is destroyed or removed from the field, this card is also destroyed.
Umi
Attrib: Magic Card
Group: Magic
Icon:Field
Increases the ATK and DEF of all Fish, Sea Serpent, Thunder, and Aqua-Type monsters by 200 points. Also decreases the ATK and DEF of all Machine and Pyro-Type monsters by 200 points.
scenario
player 1 has umi face up and tornado wall face up
player 2 plays another umi from his hand , sending the previus one to grave
the question is
just send umi is enough to trigguer the condition placed on tornado wall?
"When "Umi" is destroyed or removed from the field, this card is also destroyed."
in regards to previous rules on maiden of aqua versus tornado wall versus umi
If "Maiden of the Aqua", "Umi", and "Tornado Wall" are all on your side of the field, and "Umi" is destroyed, "Tornado Wall" is not destroyed because "Maiden of the Aqua" treats the field as "Umi" as soon as "Umi" leaves play.
the answer would be : since the final result of send umi to grave is that umi(2) remain on the field, tornado wall would remain too, by extrapolating the rule above
fact is , i am not satisfied with this rules because the condition placed on "tornado wall"
i also will coment another rule based on toons
"when toon world is destroyd all toons on both sides of the field are destroyed too"
once a condition is placed on toon monsters that they must be destroyed if a toon world leaves the field. it will afct both sides of the field
in similar manner, once the condition place on "tornado wall" is met, he also should leave the field
i will thanks any imput
woltarr