Burial from the different dimension+macro cosmos+necroface

M

mastellone

New Member
Hi,if i have necroface removed from play and macro cosmos active on the field,could i activate BFTDD targeting NECROFACE?

If i'll do that what will appening?Necroface would be removed from play again,and so his effect will be reset,or maybe nothing???
 
Sort by date Sort by votes
Necroface:
When this card is Normal Summoned, shuffle all removed from play cards into their owner's Decks. This card gains 100 ATK for each of those cards. When this card is removed from play, both players remove from play the top 5 cards of their Deck.

Activating Burial would only place Necroface and the other cards into the player's decks. Having Macros on the field redirects cards from the hand, deck or field to the graveyard. Macros doesn't remove cards already in the graveyard from play.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I think he means, if Necroface is returned to the Graveyard by Burial from a Different Dimension (BfaDD), would she be removed from play by Macro Cosmos, thus activating her effect?

The answer is no, but I'm not sure of the reason. Either:

(1) Macro Cosmos would redirect the cards to the RFP Zone, so BfaDD wouldn't do anything - it would send cards from the RFP Zone to the RFP Zone. Thus, it would have no effect, so it couldn't be activated.

(2) Since the card is already Removed From Play, Macro Cosmos would have no effect on BfaDD, since you can't send cards from the RFP Zone to the RFP Zone. Thus, BfaDD could activate and would send cards to the Graveyard, and Macro Cosmos would do nothing.

I'm leaning towards (2).
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
If you can even activate "Burial from the Different Dimension" while "Macro Cosmos" is active (this has yet to be clarified by UDE/Konami), then nothing would happen. "Burial from the Different Dimension" would attempt to return the monster to the Graveyard, but "Macro Cosmos" would redirect it to the RFP zone.

End result..the monster doesn't go anywhere...it will not leave the RFP zone.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
skey23 said:
If you can even activate "Burial from the Different Dimension" while "Macro Cosmos" is active (this has yet to be clarified by UDE/Konami), then nothing would happen. "Burial from the Different Dimension" would attempt to return the monster to the Graveyard, but "Macro Cosmos" would redirect it to the RFP zone.

End result..the monster doesn't go anywhere...it will not leave the RFP zone.
Click to expand...


Really thanks,there's no specified ruling for this type of situation and interaction with necroface,so i was really confused.Rumors about more information?

I have to dispute Paraoh tour final this sunday and i think to run a necroface deck(do you have any tech just to tell me?)

:D
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I don't know, it doesn't make much sense to be able to send something from the RFP Zone to the RFP Zone. That's why I think that (if Burial from a Different Dimension could be activated) it would override the effect of Macro Cosmos, and return cards to the Graveyard.

Hey, at least we agree that activating it in the first place is iffy, no?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top