Roc from the Valley of Haze

Zarem

New Member
On netrep.net there is two diffrent rulings on RDS-EN015 says to return it to your hand , the SD8-EN012 says to return to the deck and shuffled.
Which ruling do I use?
 
SD8 is the latest re-print, so use that. Also, I'm not sure that it ever had an effect of returning to your hand when discarded. o_O It goes to your deck and is then shuffled in.
 
Zarem said:
On netrep.net there is two diffrent rulings on RDS-EN015 says to return it to your hand , the SD8-EN012 says to return to the deck and shuffled.
Which ruling do I use?
You follow the text of the card. The typo on Netrep is beside the point.
 
Ok, I don't know what you're seeing, but both of the links you provided say the same thing..

"Because this effect is a mandatory Trigger Effect, you cannot "miss the timing" with it. So even if you send "Roc from the Valley of Haze" to the Graveyard as a cost, or in the middle of a chain, it will still be shuffled into your Deck (after resolving the current series of events)."

Which is exactly what the Netrep site says AND the UDE FAQ.
 
It's all fixed now anyway. I didn't hit a certain button after I did the update last night, which left certain things in limbo.

Looks good to me all around now.
 
Back
Top