Search results

  1. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    In the example I was mentioning, Jowgen was not on the field when Monster Reborn was activated, however, after call was activated in responce, Jowgen appeared on the field (brought back by call) before Monster Reborn resolves, but after it was activated.
  2. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    The point that I was trying to make with Jowgen + Call of the Haunted Vs Monster Reborn, is that it is possible to have Monster Reborn resolve properly, and yet not have the monster targeted by it Special Summoned to the field. This would seem to imply that whether the monster is Special...
  3. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    The point that I was trying to make with Jowgen + Call of the Haunted Vs Monster Reborn, is that there is a card in which the card Special Summoning the monster would resolve properly (since Jowgen can't negate the activate of Monster Reborn, or even make its activation invalid), but yet the...
  4. T

    Snatch Steal Vs Giant Trunade

    I still don't get how Change of Heart/Mind Control put a condition on the monster requiring it to return. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but don't most (if not all) other cards that have the phrase on it "Until end of Turn" simply expire at the end of the turn in which it was played? Why...
  5. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    DaGuyWitBluGlasses said "There's no chain point. Special summons by a cards own effect has the same mechanic as a normal summon -Announce a summon -Pay any costs (Tribute, remove monster from play) -Show the monster to the opponent -Both Players have the chance to negate the summon -The...
  6. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    The point that I was trying to make, is that if you are using Horn of Heaven to negate BLS (after its effect has been activated to speical summon itself to the field), then aren't you also chaining horn to negate its summoning in mid resolution, unless there is a Chain Point before the summoning...
  7. T

    Snatch Steal Vs Giant Trunade

    Just wondering, how can Snatch Steal still have a target if it is no longer on the field? We know what its target was, but can Snatch Steal really have a target if it no longer exists on the field?
  8. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    I actually forgot about monsters such as Gate Guardian (granted they are almost never used). Here is what I don't get. You can use BTH on monster that were special summoned by other monsters effects, as well as their own becasue there is a chain point to which you can activate such traps...
  9. T

    Quick Little Question

    Why can't you? If a replay occurs, doesn't that mean that BLS never attacked in the first place. I believe that BLS only loses his ability to remove things (for the turn) if he actually attacks, not simply having an attack declared with him. Since the attack never occured, I can't we why you...
  10. T

    Snatch Steal Vs Giant Trunade

    I was just wondering what would happen to a stolen monster (via Snatch Steal) if someone played Giant Trunade removing Snatch Steal from the field?
  11. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    I'm just wondering, if Komei never meant for Horn of Heaven to be used against monsters summoned by other card's effect, then why did they say it could negate Special Summons in the first place (since monster that could Special summon themselves appears in the sets after Horn of Heaven)...
  12. T

    Horn of Heaven Vs monsters special summoned by other monster's effects

    I was just wondering if you could use Horn of Heaven to negate the summon of a monster that was special summoned by the effect of another monster for example Shinning Angel. Any help on this would be appreacated. Thanks.
  13. T

    Torrential Tribute

    I like to think of it this way. When you opponet plays a monster, you get two chance to respond to the summoning. The first is to negate the summon of the monster, in which case, there is nothing left to respond to (expect the card used to negate the summon of the monster itself). This is...
  14. T

    Hand of Nephthys & Torrential Tribute

    I believe that the Pheniox would still get Special Summoned, since the effects would resolve as a chain with Torrential Tribute being step 1, and Hand's effect being Step 2. It would look something like this: Step one: Torrential Tribute is resolves, destoring all monsters (expect hand, and...
  15. T

    Phoenix Wing Wind Blast VS. Monster Token

    I think that you can use PWWB on the monster token, since it is a monster. However, it would be destoried, rather than sent back to the top of you opponet's deck, since tokens can't ever be place in a player's deck. I'm not sure how this is all revelant to Creature Swap however. Since...
  16. T

    Solemn Judgment MRD-127

    I love this card, it works perfectly with Last Turn, protecting it from anything that you opponet might what to try (since half of your life can't ever kill you). I run three of these with two Masks of Darkness (mainly so I can get them back. Aslo, if you run a trap Heavy Deck like I do...
  17. T

    Solemn Judgement Vs Barrel Behind the Door: When do I pay half my life?

    I was just wondering, if my opponet uses Ring of Destruction on a monster, and then chains Barrel to it (in this case, I am assuming that I chain nothing in response to ring), and then I decide to use Solemn Judgement to negate his/her Barrel, do I pay half of my life before or after ring...
  18. T

    Jowgen the Spiritualist + Last Turn DOESN'T WORK!

    I'd still like to know what the difference is between, the battle phase which is entered via Last Turn, and the "regular battle phase" that everyone is talking about. Where does Last Turn mention that it give you opponet an extra battle phase? As far as I know, unless a card grants a player an...
  19. T

    Horus lv6

    Why can Horus LV 6 attack through swords of revealing light? Swords specifically says that you opponet cannot declare an attack. How does this effect Horus LV 6? If you opponet can't declare an attack, what does it matter if Horus LV 6 is on their side of the field. If there is any errta to...
  20. T

    Waboku -- The Great Emissary of "Disharmony"

    Great article. I have one question though. Wouldn't Spirit Reaper still get its effect if it attacked you opponet directly, since Spirit Reaper only states that it must attack you opponet directly to get its effect, and says nothing about actually damaging you opponet, or inflecting battle...
Back
Top