Cyber Jar vs Solemn Judgment
- Thread starter SPK
- Start date
darkjason
New Member
No.
The special summoning via Cyber Jar is within a monster effect. Solemn Judgment would have to interrupt the resolution of Cyber Jar's effect in order to negate the summon, which it can't do.
If however Cyber Jar was flip summoned instead of flipped by an attack (or by some effect, eg. Swords, Desert Sunlight), you could negate the entire effect by negating the flip summon.
The special summoning via Cyber Jar is within a monster effect. Solemn Judgment would have to interrupt the resolution of Cyber Jar's effect in order to negate the summon, which it can't do.
If however Cyber Jar was flip summoned instead of flipped by an attack (or by some effect, eg. Swords, Desert Sunlight), you could negate the entire effect by negating the flip summon.
This isn't necessarilly correct on the second part there.
Swords of Revealing Light and Desert Sunlight don't flip summon anything. They change the battle position with flip effects and certain other monster effects (Tsukuyomi and Nightmare Penguin for example) will activate. Cyber Jar wasn't flip summoned, there for Solemn Judgment can't activate. It would be chaining to the monster's effect that activated. Which is an illegal activation.
But if Solemn Judgment is activated in response to the Flip Summoning, then yes, Cyber Jar's effect won't activate.
Swords of Revealing Light and Desert Sunlight don't flip summon anything. They change the battle position with flip effects and certain other monster effects (Tsukuyomi and Nightmare Penguin for example) will activate. Cyber Jar wasn't flip summoned, there for Solemn Judgment can't activate. It would be chaining to the monster's effect that activated. Which is an illegal activation.
But if Solemn Judgment is activated in response to the Flip Summoning, then yes, Cyber Jar's effect won't activate.
Chillout1984
New Member
Tkwiget said:
He doesn't say that Cyber Jar is flip-summoned by Swords or Desert Sunlight, he says that Cyber Jar is flipped up by an effect and took those 2 cards as an example
