More End Phase headaches!

skey23

Council of Heroes
Ok, since we're doing End Phase resolutions and what not...here's one I'm 'stealing' from another site because it's brought up a few questions in my mind that I'm not entirely sure how to resolve...lol.

P1 has a face-up "Gemini Elf" and a face-down "Archfiend Soldier", on the field.
P1 also has an "Enemy Controller" set from a previous turn.
P2 has no monsters and "Brain Control" in hand.
P2 activates "Brain Control", paying the 800 LPs, and targeting "Gemini Elf".
P1 does not respond.
P2 does not respond.
P2 now has control of "Gemini Elf".
P2 moves to Battle Phase and declares attack with "Gemini Elf".
P1 responds with "Enemy Controller", choosing the 2nd effect and tributing their face-down monster to take control of "Gemini Elf".
P2 does not respond.
P1 does not respond.
P1 now has "Gemini Elf" again.
P2 ends their turn.

Ok, so how does this resolve?

Can P2 even resolve the effect of "Brain Control" if the monster is no longer on their side of the field?

The 'ideal' resolution would be this:
P2 retains Priority to resolve "Brain Control", but passes.
P1 chooses to resolve "Enemy Controller" and "Gemini Elf" goes back to P2.
P2 now must resolve "Brain Control" and "Gemini Elf" goes back to P1.
End turn.

But what happens when P2 tries to resolve "Brain Control" w/o actually having control of the monster?

Alternate resolution:
P2 retains Priority to resolve "Brain Control" but passes.
P1 Passes on resolving "Enemy Controller".
P2 MUST resolve "Brain Control", but there is no monster. "Brain Control"s effect disappears?
P1 now resolves "Enemy Controller" and P2 gets "Gemini Elf" where it will stay since "Brain Control"s effect has been forced to activate already?

THIS is truly confusing..lol.
 
Hmm, intriguing indeed.

My thought is this. We know that you can't activate/resolve effects that will do nothing. So the player must wait until the Gemini Elf is back on their side of the field in order to revert control of it back.

Now we know that if Gemini Elf was destroyed in the midst of all of this, there would be no effects to resolve at all, because the monster is no longer on the field, so it seems that the "returning" effect would be a lingering condition placed upon Gemini Elf.

Additionally, the condition placed on this monster isn't as literal and hard lined like "Return control to Johnny" more of a "Return control to opponent" and these would resolve themselves in reverse order that they were activated. That way no matter how crazy the chain gets built, the control returning aspects of things aren't controlled by the players and they will resolve to their rightful owner.

...then again, that makes NO sense when you take Ectoplasmer into consideration, so I guess this is a lot of fluff 8^D
 
Well from how I understand the way targetting effects resolve outstanding effects, I'd have to say this.

If P2 is forced to resolve the effect of Brain Control and doesn't control the monster, the effect of Brain Control will disappear. Then P1 has the last outstanding effect to resolve. P1 gives control of Gemini Elf back to P2.

Brain Control and Enemy Controller (2nd effect) have effects that are like a light switch. You turn on and off the controlling effect when they attempt to resolve. If one controlling effect disappears, then that control switch is automatically turned off. Enemy Controller is the last card to have an outstanding effect that will turn on or off the control of Gemini Elf.

In this case the effect of Enemy Controller will resolve and turn off the control of Gemini Elf with P1 and turn it on with P2. No other outstanding effects are present to resolve and Gemini Elf stays on P2's field.

Not like my opinion means much. @_@
 
p1 enemy controller user becomes link 2 on the chain block
and p2 brain controller user becomes link 1 on the chain block

and we resolve end to beggining

so enemy gives creatures to p2
then p2 gives creatures back to p1.

remember priority means your always first on the chain block, or atleast first to put stuff on there.

and since p1 the enemy controller player isnt the turn player they will go on the block after the p2 brain controller puts their effect on the chain block.

it cant go off of that balance. or atleast i dont think it can.
 
Umm, both cards resolved already. Their outstanding effects in the End Phase is what are trying to resolve. That's what I was focusing on with my post. =/
 
Tkwiget said:
Umm, both cards resolved already. Their outstanding effects in the End Phase is what are trying to resolve. That's what I was focusing on with my post. =/
im not talking about the cards phisically im talking about their effects.

the game itself automatically places both effects at the end phase.

the only time you get a choice is when multiple of your effects get placed at the same time, then you choice the order. in this case you choose nothing since the game just places stuff in that order.
 
I was talking about their effects as well. So far I haven't been talking about anything other than them.

Outstanding effects never create a chain block; card activation and effect activations do. You first start with the Turn Player and if that player decides to resolve something then it goes to the other player to resolve their effect or pass it back to the Turn Player.

In the scenario, P2 is the Turn Player.

If P2 doesn't control the Gemini Elf when he attempts to resolve the outstanding effect of Brain Control, the effect disappears. Then the last outstanding effect must resolve. P2 will gain control of Gemini Elf.

You can't resolve an outstanding effect if that effect isn't there to resolve.

P2 passes to P1.
P1 passes back to P2.
P2 must resolve Brain Control. The outstanding effect of Brain Control disappears.
P1 must now resolve his effect because it's the last outstanding effect to resolve. Enemy Controller resolves and P2 gains control of Gemini Elf.

There isn't any chain block created in the End Phase of this scenario.
 
krazykidpsx said:
im not talking about the cards phisically im talking about their effects.

the game itself automatically places both effects at the end phase.

the only time you get a choice is when multiple of your effects get placed at the same time, then you choice the order. in this case you choose nothing since the game just places stuff in that order.
You do NOT place effects on a chian during the end phase.

Effects that are supposed to resolve in the End Phase are NOT simultaneous.
 
so then what the heck does happend at end phase?

you know what, i dont wish to know, but i still stand in trowing out the question becuase really you know how odd that is?

its like how tsukuyomi returns to my hand before my discard step. what the deal with that? no?
 
"Take control of the selected monster until the End Phase of this turn."

Seems to me that the effect will always return the monster to the owner of the monster, not the opponent of the controller of the effect.
Wynn the Wind Charmer
If you take control of the opponent's monster with a "Charmer" and the opponent takes control back with "Change of Heart", control still reverts to you after the effect of "Change of Heart" expires (even though it wasn't your monster originally).​
If control wouldn't ordinarly go back to the owner of the card, then why make phrase the ruling this way? Didn't we already go through this with two Change of Hearts? I don't see any difference.
 
Entropy said:
This reminds me of this. Food for thought.

http://lists.upperdeck.com/read/messages?id=6185#6185

Warning: the following is purely guessing.

Anyone else think that the effects will cancel each other out, so that no control switching takes place during the End Phase? The above message seems to say that two control switches cancel each other out.

...Remember, guessing.
The reason the monster stays in this ruling instance (the one you linked to) is because "Creature Swap" gave permanent control back to the original owner of the monster. The scenario I put forth doesn't involve any sort of permanent control.
 
Digital Jedi said:
"Take control of the selected monster until the End Phase of this turn."

Seems to me that the effect will always return the monster to the owner of the monster, not the opponent of the controller of the effect.
Wynn the Wind Charmer
If you take control of the opponent's monster with a "Charmer" and the opponent takes control back with "Change of Heart", control still reverts to you after the effect of "Change of Heart" expires (even though it wasn't your monster originally).​
If control wouldn't ordinarly go back to the owner of the card, then why make phrase the ruling this way? Didn't we already go through this with two Change of Hearts? I don't see any difference.
Ok, but the example you posted doesn't match with what you're saying...lol. The player with the "Charmer" is not the 'owner' of the card in your post, yet "Change of Heart" still returns it to the opponent of the controller of the effect (to use your words).
 
krazykidpsx said:
actaully you bring up something good, Why not send the question to the Judges list?
Honestly, because I know it will never be answered....lol. Or, at least, it won't be answered any time soon. I'd rather wait and hash it out here, or post it to the Level 3 list when I finally get access.
 
skey23 said:
Ok, but the example you posted doesn't match with what you're saying...lol. The player with the "Charmer" is not the 'owner' of the card in your post, yet "Change of Heart" still returns it to the opponent of the controller of the effect (to use your words).
The controller of the Charmer gets the monster back because his Charmer is still face-up in the End Phase. The ruling seems to imply that if the Charmer hadn't been face-up on the field, then control would have remained with the owner, the player who played Change of Heart.

If Change of Heart returns monsters to the previous controller, rather then the owner, then this ruling is superfluous. Change of Heart is a timed effect granting control of a monster. When it times out, it looks for ownership.
 
Change of Heart doesn't look for ownership at all, it has not concept of that. In general ownership only applies to effects that deal with the hand, deck, graveyard or rfp. It returns to the previous player who had permanant control.

In the case of the Charmer ruling, control reverts back to the Charmer's side because it's effect is similar to Snatch Steal, and is a Continuous control effect that will suck the monster back in after all temporary control effects expire.

If the Charmer were to be destroyed prior to Change of Heart ending then control would remain with the player who played Change of Heart, not because he/she is the owner, but because he or she was the last player to have permanent control of the monster.
 
P1 would gain control of Gemini Elf after all is said and done, regardless of resolution order because he/she was that last player to have permanent control of it.

2 similar control effect are overlapping here, and they are both temporaries, so the last permanent controller gains control.


Another example:

My opponent Monster Reborn's my Chaos Sorceror, and i Snatch Steal it back, then he Snatch Steal's it back again. If i were to play Heavy Storm, my opponent would gain control of CS in the end due to him being the last permanent controller.
 
I'm still not sure about the whole 'permanent' control thing, especially with cards like "Brain Control" and "Enemy Controller".

Here's an example of what I'm talking about....

http://lists.upperdeck.com/read/messages?id=3042#3042


In this P1 has permanent control.
P2 uses "Snatch Steal".
P1 then uses "Change of Heart"
The monster gets turned face-down by "Book of Moon".
"Snatch Steal" gets destroyed by game mechanic.

According to you, the monster will stay with P1 since they were the last one to have 'permanent' control ("Snatch Steal" is not permanent control). But as you can see, "Change of Heart"s effect doesn't care about that. All it sees is it has a monster from the opponent, and it must return that monster back to the person it came from. So that's what it does.

This is what's got me all confused. "Brain Control" and "Enemy Controller" behave identically to "Change of Heart" in that last respect. All they care about is returning the monster they took back to where it came from, no matter who it came from.
 
Back
Top