ChaosMachine
New Member
If Jinzo is one of the monsters special summoned by return from the different dimension will he negate them being removed from play at the end of the turn?
Complex_Mind said:Ok then. Let me ask YOU. In the four pages of this thread, Where has it gone? I'll answer for you. Nowhere. Everyone is sticking to their opinions and no one is LEARNING anything. Why doesn't someone step up and just email upperdeck for an explanation obviously no one HERE can give? I'm sorry if I'm offending anyone. I'm only saying what needs to be said.
We're lucky to get a couple of posts a week on it.
paulb91085 said:[ycard="FET-EN052]Threatening Roar[/ycard] doesn't target any monster follow the simlar ruling with to [ycard="SDJ-046]Waboku[/ycard] ( can still attack but doesn't kill monster unless it's D.D Warrior Lady) :icon_cry:
...and I still say (but when did I say it before?) that that is a rock-solid argument. [ycard="FET-EN052]Threatening Roar[/ycard] is a trap version of Swords. Both claim to prevent a player from attacking, yet it has been ruled that monsters attack, not players.John Danker said:The counter argument to that is that [ycard="SD1-EN014]Swords of Revealing Light[/ycard] doesn't target any monsters either and monsters that are uneffected by spell cards can still attack. We've been through that paticular argument ....but thank you for your input.
Phase vs Attack.slither said:I had brought out to the attention on another site, a similar text with a different effect, which was [ycard="SDY-041]Soul Exchange[/ycard], it also claims that the "player" is not able to conduct his/her battle phase, now why would monsters unaffected by spell cards unable to ignore this effect? and why would they be able to ignore TR then? if it also places a restriction to the player.
That would markedly different. The Game is what is affected here, and not the player or the monster. Everyone and evrything must be able to enter each phase, regardless of who decides who enters that phase each turn. Without a Battle Phase there can be no attacks. If the game cannot progress into the battle phase due to the effect of a Spell Card, the a monster unafected by Spell Cards would still not be able to attack because the game never progresses to the only phase he is capable of attaking in.slither said:I had brought out to the attention on another site, a similar text with a different effect, which was [ycard="SDY-041]Soul Exchange[/ycard], it also claims that the "player" is not able to conduct his/her battle phase, now why would monsters unaffected by spell cards unable to ignore this effect? and why would they be able to ignore TR then? if it also places a restriction to the player.